This week I have had the opportunity to
consider how I engage ethics in the workplace. It is clear that ethical
behavior is not just based on individual choice. Ethical behavior is also
social and collective. I understand that some people have a hard time accepting
organizational factors because of the emphasis it takes away from personal
moral responsibility, but the organizational factors cannot be denied. The idea
that we have to have one or the other – organization or individual – is a false
dichotomy. Identifying that there are organizational factors does not negate
the importance of individual choice and behavior. This is a both/and situation.
Organizations are made up of people and those
people are put in environments as representatives of those organizations where
they have to make decisions. At times it may be hard for individuals to discern
what the most appropriate behavior or choice might be. Employers and leaders of
organizations are responsible for the conduct of their employees and the
choices that are made and therefore have a responsibility at the front-end to
create an environment where ethical behavior is the expectation and the norm.
Creating this environment is challenging – no doubt – but so is directly
affecting individual behavior.
As I considered organizational ethics, I decided
to ask around the non-profit where I work about a code of ethics. It turns out,
we have a code of ethics we sign when we start our employment. We sign it at
the same time that we sign the employee handbook. In my six years here I have
never heard it mentioned again. I asked other co-workers if they knew anything
about it and none did! Some remembered signing it – but no one could remember anything
about it. Of course our HR person knew and the director knew- but no one else. I
did get a copy of the code and used it to consider some information on
organizational ethics.
Some background: The
organization where I work is a non-profit community center that has been
serving the same community for nearly 80 years. We have 8 program areas serving
mainly women and children of all ages – literally from 5 to 105! We have around
30 employees with a mostly flat organizational structure. There is a very
active Board of Directors and an Executive Director who answers to the board.
Then there are four of us who are considered supervisors. We all supervise a
different number of people who range from 4 hour a week employees to full-time.
We all have a variety of educational and ministry background depending on our
positions. We are located in west Georgia in a city of nearly 200,000.
Our Code of Ethics is made up of twenty bullet points mostly
beginning with the words “I will…” or “I will not…” Most of the points
have to do with virtue ethics - personal rectitude and being a person of integrity.
Examples of those statements include: “I will act in accordance with standards
of professional integrity” and “I will accurately represent my education,
training, experience and competencies as they relate to my profession.”
A few of the statements could be based in duty ethics
including: “I will abide by Open Door Community House, Inc. policies related to
public statements” and “I will not engage in or condone any form of
harassment or discrimination.” And there were a couple of statements that could
be evaluated by a results-based approach. One of those statements reads:
“If I know that a colleague has violated ethical standards, I will bring this
to my colleague’s attention. If this fails, I will report that activity to the
director.”
I can
think of several things that might make it easier to consider ethics in my
workplace. The first suggestion would be for employees to be reminded of this
code! If this is something we’re intended to follow and pay attention to, it is
important we know it exists! There are several practical ways I can imagine
using to remind employees of the code and why it is important.
I also think there are some points that seem vague and some that
seem very specific. The vague ideas need to be clarified and made relevant to
the work employees are doing. I think it would be helpful to spend time talking
about how the points mentioned in the code of ethics could directly relate to
the choices made and work done by employees. It might even be helpful to guide
employees in some sort of case study analyses considering ethics in a variety
of situations. The very specific items make me wonder if some of the things
were added because of specific circumstances that either happened here at this
organization or at another local or similar place. It would be helpful to know
the history of our code of ethics – where it came from and when changes have
been made.
It is clear that organizations have culture and ethics are a
part of that culture. It is the responsibility of leadership to model and
cultivate that culture, but the responsibility of everyone to participate in
making ethical choices that contribute to an ethical organization.
I thought this was an interesting info-graphic.
Mary this was a great blog. Ethics in the workplace is collective. It all depends on the morale and feel of the office. The leaders and managers of each respective organization are responsible for the office environment and should lead by example. I can understand how it may be difficult to create a certain type of environment when you have just as many personalities as personnel. When discussing your organization’s code of ethics, it brings me to one of the response’s I received on my post from this week asking how often code of ethics is brought up and your response was mine. We sign it with new employee orientation material and so it gets placed in each individual’s personnel file. This is what happens for most people and some employees do not even read the material they just sign away. Enjoyed reading your blog Mary!
ReplyDeleteMary – I really enjoyed reading your blog post for this week’s topic. I ran into the same problem with my employer regarding their Code of Ethics. It is a document that they make you sign acknowledgement for when you are hired and then you never hear another word about it. I researched the Code of Ethics for the organization that I actually work for (employed through one and work for a different one) and the only think I could find was a Code of Ethics for Social Networking. Now I am not saying that the organization does not have a Code of Ethics but it is not easily accessible to employees. I think the last graphic you included speaks volumes to workplace ethics.
ReplyDelete